Latest Safety & HR News

24 January 2018

Use the gear you’ve got

That is the lesson following the sentencing of Stumpmaster Limited today in the North Shore District Court. Stumpmaster was cutting down a palm tree from a property when a woman walked into the path of the falling tree.  The victim suffered fractures and a laceration which required six days hospitalisation.

Safety gear is no good when it is sitting in your vehicle – and it needs to be used properly.

WorkSafe’s investigation found that there was no effective exclusion zone around the tree work to ensure public safety. Stumpmaster had placed three cones in the area, but they were not placed two tree-lengths from the tree being felled and there was no attempt to cordon off the area to restrict access or notify the public of the works.

Stumpmaster had suitable signage available at its office and extendable barriers and tape in its vehicle at the site.

WorkSafe’s Deputy General Manager, Investigations and Specialist Services Simon Humphries said that the incident was completely avoidable.

“Stumpmaster had extendable barriers and tape available to mark out an exclusion zone but chose not to use it.  As a result, an innocent party has received traumatic injuries.”

“You are responsible for ensuring that other people are not put at risk by the work of your business.  This includes members of the public who could be affected by a work activity”.


  • Stumpmaster Limited was convicted and fined $90,000 and ordered to pay $18,500 reparation to the victim.
  • Stumpmaster Limited was sentenced under sections 36(2), 48(1) and (2)(c) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015.
    • Being a PCBU, failed to ensure, so far as was reasonably practicable, that the health and safety of other persons was not put at risk from work being carried out as part of conduct of the business or undertaking, and that failure exposed other persons to a risk of death or serious injury.
  • The maximum penalty was a fine not exceeding $1,500,000.

» Read original article here


The lesson from this case is the importance of ensuring all your safety risk controls are in place and that the mechanisms are also in place to provide assurance over control effectiveness. 


The latest estimate for failure to adequately address safety concerns globally has been put at 3.9% of the global GDP.  In dollar terms that is US$2.99 Trillion.

David Buchanan
Buchanan Painting and Waterblasting
Jim Pope from Hauraki Health and Safety has done what he said he would do. I can now focus on building my business knowing that Jim has my back. He manages my safety for me, is dealing with my pre-qualification (which I found confusing) and he has given me an app to use which means no paper, no worries and no having to work after hours on safety stuff. It really is nice knowing that I don’t have to do this because Jim is.”
Tracey Petterson
PTP Services Ltd
I engaged Jim to provide me with my HR when I purchased my business. Sometimes I could just hug him! He keeps things simple for me and gives me confidence that I am doing the right things. I understand the importance to receive HR advice that is professional and current with the latest NZ employment rules, so it is nice having him in my back pocket when I need his help. He is so easy to deal with, nothing is ever a problem and his advice is honest, even if I don’t want to hear it. I am getting from him exactly what I need. He is definitely worth the investment.

Sign up for our Newsletter

We will publish regular updates and advice about safety & HR as well as the latest safety & employment relations news and what this means for you.